Shingle Roof Replacement in Tempe, AZ
3-tab or architectural, full tear-off, itemized written estimate — no pressure to sign before you've had a chance to compare.
4.9★
Google Rating, 187+ reviews
14 yrs
Serving the Tempe area
2,400+
Projects completed
1-2 days
Typical install time
3-tab or architectural — the real difference, not the sales pitch
Every shingle replacement quote starts with this choice, so we lead with it instead of burying it in the estimate. 3-tab is the budget option — flat profile, lower material cost, still a code-compliant, durable roof. Architectural shingle costs more per square but generally holds up better to wind and UV over time, with a dimensional look most homeowners prefer.
Neither one is the "wrong" answer. What matters is picking the one that fits your budget and how long you plan to stay in the home, not whichever one carries the bigger margin for the roofer quoting it. We'll lay out both numbers for your specific roof before you decide.
Get both options comparedWhen a shingle roof is actually due for replacement
15-20+ years old
Arizona's UV exposure shortens shingle lifespan compared to milder climates.
Curling or cupping
Shingle edges lifting or curling across most of the roof, not just one sun-exposed section.
Heavy granule loss
Bald patches on the shingles or granules collecting in the gutters.
Repeat repair calls
Two or three repair visits in a year usually costs more over time than one planned replacement.
3-tab vs. architectural shingle
| Factor | 3-tab | Architectural |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
| Profile | Flat, uniform | Dimensional, layered look |
| Wind resistance | Good | Generally better |
| Typical lifespan in Arizona | Shorter end of the range | Longer end of the range |
From estimate to a finished roof
Four steps, no surprises along the way.
Free Inspection
We walk the roof, check for curling, granule loss, and deck condition, and explain what we find.
Written Estimate
Both 3-tab and architectural priced out, itemized, with tear-off and disposal included.
Tear-Off & Install
Old shingles removed, deck checked and repaired if needed, new shingles installed to spec.
Final Walkthrough
We walk the finished roof with you before we call the job done.
How we make the call on a shingle roof
| What we look at | Repair usually fits | Replacement usually fits |
|---|---|---|
| Roof age | Under 15 years old | 15-20+ years old |
| Damage scope | Isolated to one section | Curling or granule loss across most of the roof |
| Repair history | First or second repair call | Multiple repair calls in the past year or two |
Shingle roof replacement cost factors
Asphalt shingle typically runs $4-$6 per square foot installed. What moves your specific number:
- 3-tab vs. architectural — architectural costs more per square but often performs better long-term.
- Roof size and pitch — more square footage and steeper pitch both add labor time.
- Number of layers being torn off — removing multiple existing layers costs more than one.
- Decking condition — if the deck needs repair once the old shingles are off, that's a documented add, not a surprise.
- Roof complexity — multiple planes, valleys, and penetrations add flashing work.
See our full roof replacement cost guide for pricing across every material, and our tile vs. shingle comparison if you're weighing a material switch entirely.
Other ways we can help
Shingle roof replacement questions
Is architectural shingle worth the extra cost over 3-tab?
For most homeowners planning to stay put, yes — architectural shingle typically lasts longer, handles wind better, and holds up to Arizona UV exposure more consistently than 3-tab. If budget is the deciding factor, 3-tab is still a legitimate, code-compliant option; we'll lay out the real cost difference for your roof size during the estimate rather than push one over the other.
Can you just repair the worst sections instead of a full reroof?
If damage is isolated, yes — that's a job for our repair team, not a reroof. Full replacement makes sense once curling, granule loss, or wear shows up across most of the roof, or the roof has crossed the 15-20 year mark typical for shingle in this climate.
How do I know 15-20 years is really up and this isn't premature?
We'll show you what we find during the free inspection — granule loss, curling, brittle shingles, or exposed nail heads are the visual signs, not just a birthday on the roof. If your roof still has real life left, we'll tell you that.
How long does shingle replacement take start to finish?
Most single-family shingle replacements take one to two days on site, depending on roof size, pitch, and how many layers need tearing off.
Do you handle tear-off and disposal?
Yes, tear-off and disposal are included and itemized in the written estimate — not an add-on surprise at the end.
Can you install over my existing shingles instead of tearing off?
Roofing over an existing layer is sometimes an option depending on current condition and local code limits on layer count, but a full tear-off gives us a chance to check the deck underneath — we'll walk you through the tradeoffs for your specific roof.
Ready to compare 3-tab and architectural side by side?
Get a free inspection and a written estimate for both — no pressure either way.